I finished reading the book version of Julie & Julia earlier today just in time to see the movie tonight. Before I had even started the book, I had an inkling that the movie was going to
be better, and that is not often said of movies made from books. As a matter of fact, the movie “Julie & Julia” is based on two books – Julie & Julia by Julie Powell, and My Life in France by Julia Child. (So it was kind of like seeing a movie that I only knew half of already.) The basic premise of the book is of Julie Powell, a crass, arrogant chic living in New York and temping for government agencies stumbles upon Mastering the Art of French Cooking while visiting her mom in Texas, decides to cook all 524 recipes in a year and blog about it each day. I had high hopes for the movie given Nora Ephron’s direction and my previous liking of her movies. (Think: “You’ve Got Mail” and “Sleepless in Seattle.”)
As I started reading the book, I realized part of my problem: I did not see Amy Adams as Julie Powell. Amy Adams is such a likable girl in all her roles; she’s not a snarky, f-bomb dropper who doesn’t care about victims of 9-11. But I see why her demeanor was changed for the movie – the audience needs a likable protagonist. End of story.
Here’s my other problem: In the world of “self-discovery memoirs,” the reader expects some kind of big life change or dramatic revelation by the author at the close of their journey. Upon finishing the book, my thought was, “Ok, so she cooked through Mastering the Art of French Cooking in a year, and I’m still really not sure why exactly, and she’s not even a changed person.” Because isn’t that the whole purpose behind these projects?
Like I mentioned earlier, the movie also incorporated the memoir My Life in France by Julia Child. And by incorporated I mean dominated. Meryl Streep did an amazing job portraying her, which is no surprise. (I know this is very shallow, but I have to be honest – her voice was really getting on my nerves starting halfway through. I know that’s how she talked though.) For me it was interesting, though, because I didn’t really know anything about her or her life, other than she was a world-famous television cook and cookbook author.
Together Amy Adams and Meryl Streep make the movie very likable as their respective characters, and food-centered movies are always fun for an aspiring chef like myself. If you’re sitting here thinking about whether to either read the book or see the movie, I would suggest ditching the book and checking out the movie. Is it theater-worthy? Maybe. Or maybe just wait until next weekend to see “The Time Traveller’s Wife.”


really quick read, no pun intended (or maybe it is?), and I devoured it very fast – about two days of camping fast. “The Quickie” reminded my why I’m a fan of mystery/thriller novels and I realized I should read more.
whirl. “Nothing But the Truth” is the story of a reporter who prints a news story revealing the identity of a CIA operative, and is then jailed when asked to reveal her source and will not do so. It stars Kate Beckinsale, Matt Dillon, David Schwimmer, Angela Bassett, Noah Wyle and Vera Farmiga. The story, which is inspired by true events, is very interesting and the movie is well-paced and holds your attention throughout. I found myself yelling at the TV, “Just give up your source already!” But what I was really impressed with was actress Vera Farmiga’s acting chops. I hadn’t seen or heard of her before this movie, although she was in “The Departed,” (which I haven’t seen) and a slew of indie films. (Coincidentally a few days later, I received my Cookie magazine in the mail and she was on the cover, so I got to familiarize myself with her that way. )
n is featured in this movie as well. Watch the trailer
around to seeing it so here’s my thoughts.
For those of you who know me, you know that I am a huge movie buff, so I thought I’d include my movie reviews in my “new and improved” blog, in addition to recipes, book reviews, and more.